Vice City Playbook
Outcomes reported by five guides · the $10,000 payout is disputed by one

GTA 6 Arnold: kill or spare, and what each choice changes

Last checked: . This page is part of the spoiler section. The story details are hidden until you press the button.

Spoiler-free answer

You cannot get this choice wrong. Five guides agree that the story continues the same way with either option, and the next scene and the next mission do not change. What does change is Jason's criminal profile. One option is also reported to pay out later. Which one, and how much, is behind the button below.

Kill or spare Arnold: quick answers without spoilers

Spoiler warning

Everything below this box gives away parts of the GTA 6 story. It stays hidden until you choose to see it.

Take me to the spoiler-free guides

Short answer

Sparing Arnold is the better pick according to the guides that recommend one. Sparing him moves Jason's criminal profile toward the restrained side, and two outlets report that Arnold later sends Jason $10,000. Killing him moves the profile toward Hardened and pays nothing. The story, the next scene and the next mission are the same either way, and no guide reports an effect on the ending.

Kill or spare Arnold: side by side

SpareKill
Criminal profileToward Restrained, the less violent sideToward Hardened
Money$10,000 later in the story (reported by two outlets, doubted by one)Nothing
ArnoldSwims awayGone from the story
Next scene and next missionSameSame
EndingNo effect reportedNo effect reported

When the choice comes

What happens if you spare Arnold

The payout is not settled. Gamer Tweak calls the $10,000 unconfirmed and notes that other walkthroughs say Arnold never returns, and SVG says he leaves for good. We keep it as Reported until we see it in the game.

What happens if you kill Arnold

One outlet names the profile result differently: SVG says a kill counts as Ruthless or Violent depending on whether it was a headshot. The other three say Hardened.

Should you kill or spare Arnold?

Spare him. Gamer Tweak and GTA6 Life both recommend it, for the same reason: killing earns nothing, and sparing costs nothing now and may pay $10,000 later. GameRant gives no pick and says to choose the kind of criminal you want Jason to be. If you are aiming for a clean profile for the end of the story, sparing also fits that: see what decides the GTA 6 ending.

Does killing or sparing Arnold change the ending?

Nothing says so. None of the five guides reports an effect on the ending, and GameRant says the choice only touches the criminal profile. The profile itself is one of the things named as shaping the ending, but one early mission moves it only a little, and Dork calls the effect short-term. The reported conditions for the best ending are on the GTA 6 endings page.

Other story choices in GTA 6

Every mission in order is on the Chapter 1 mission page and the full mission list.

Still being verified: the Island Dreams decision and later story choices, each with both outcomes, once two sources agree.

GTA 6 is out. We add this as soon as it is confirmed by Rockstar or by two independent sources. Nothing here is guessed.

FAQ

Should you kill or spare Arnold in GTA 6?

Spare him, according to the guides that give a recommendation. Killing him earns nothing, and the story continues the same way with either option.

What happens if you spare Arnold in GTA 6?

Jason's criminal profile moves toward Restrained and Arnold swims away. Two outlets report that Jason receives $10,000 later in the story, and one calls that unconfirmed.

What happens if you kill Arnold in GTA 6?

Jason's criminal profile moves toward Hardened and Arnold is gone from the story. There is no reward, and the next mission is the same.

Does the Arnold choice affect the GTA 6 ending?

No guide reports an effect on the ending as of November 20, 2026. It changes Jason's criminal profile.

Which mission has the Arnold choice in GTA 6?

Hey Arnold!, the eighth story mission of Chapter 1. Jason makes the choice at the end of the mission.

More from the spoiler section